The short answer
Visit both if you want the history of Cretan resistance in one trip: the monastery on its plateau and the cave above Melidoni. Wikipedia describes Arkadi as a well-fortified monastery with a 16th-century church in Renaissance Revival style, and a place of science and art with a school and library from the 16th century.
Arkadi Monastery
The monastery stands on a rectangular plateau on the north-west side of Mount Ida, about 500 metres above sea level, and is surrounded by a thick high wall (Wikipedia). During the Cretan revolt of 1866, 943 Greeks, mostly women and children, took refuge there. It became a national sanctuary and is commemorated on 8 November. We give no opening hours or fees because we found no sourced figures.
Melidoni Cave
German Wikipedia puts the cave above the village of Melidoni and ties it to the same resistance: in 1824, 340 villagers and 30 fighters died there in a fire. Read the cave guide for what is known and what we could not confirm.
Putting them in one day
Tour listings from Rethymno combine the cave, the monastery and Margarites village, and a private trip adds the Museum of Ancient Eleftherna. We copy no durations; compare the itineraries on the tour page and the comparison. If you drive, see how to get to Melidoni Cave.
Frequently asked questions
Can you visit Arkadi Monastery and Melidoni Cave in one day?
Yes, tour listings from Rethymno combine them, some in a half day and some with more stops. Check each itinerary for the stops and the timing.
How far is Arkadi Monastery from Rethymno?
Wikipedia gives 23 km south-east of Rethymno in its opening paragraph and 25 km in its topography section. The monastery sits on a plateau at 500 metres above sea level.
What happened at Arkadi in 1866?
Wikipedia says 943 Greeks, mostly women and children, took refuge in the monastery during the Cretan revolt and, after three days of battle, the Cretans blew up gunpowder barrels rather than surrender. It is commemorated on 8 November.
Some links are affiliate links: if you book through them we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It funds the research behind this site.